Tuesday, June 8, 2010
I Slept On The Rabbi
Monday, June 7, 2010
Rabbi Wrote Me An Email
Dear friends,
Over the weekend our office received many emails from angry women saying I had attacked breast-feeding. One woman even said I had equated breast-feeding with adultery, which has to be one of the most flagrant acts of misrepresentation I have ever encountered.
In truth, the article they were quoting, which they said was new, was written four years ago in June, 2006. Even then it was severely misrepresented, so a few months later, in August 2006, I wrote this response below, portraying my real views on the importance of both breastfeeding and marriage.
Should the need arise, I will write an even newer response so that my views are in no way misrepresented.
Thank you.
Rabbi Shmuley Boteach
My Real Views on Breastfeeding Children
By Rabbi Shmuley Boteach
But OK, if I was wrong, I’ll admit it. True, as many of you will point out, I’ve never been wrong before. But I am, after all, human, that is, unless you’re one of my breastfeeding critics, in which case I am a bushy-bearded, one-eyed Cyclops.
But first the facts.
The column I wrote was in response to a New York Times report on the benefits of breastfeeding for babies. I noted that while no one disagrees that breastfeeding is much better for a baby than formula, as a marital counselor I had seen that in some marriages, admittedly a minority, breastfeeding could come between a husband and wife, its incessant demands serving as an impediment to romance. For many couples it meant not being able to go out on a date without the baby for months, and having the baby sleep in the matrimonial bed, with the inevitable deleterious effect on the couples’ love life. My solution: if breastfeeding created distance between you and your husband, don’t feel guilty about supplementing the breast with the bottle.
Sounds innocuous, right? But the suggestion opened the floodgates of hell. Women who admired me as a lifelong champion of women’s rights, in books like ‘Hating Women’ and ‘Kosher Sex,’ felt betrayed. They were now calling me a misogynist because, in their mind, I took the side of male chauvinists whose selfish claim on their wives’ time imperiled their children, and whose need to eroticize their wives’ breasts took precedence over the role of the breast in feeding a child.
Commentary on the article exploded all over the internet with the inevitable misquotation and misrepresentation. Suddenly, I was reading how I had dismissed breastfeeding as unsexy and destructive to marriages. Women’s breasts’ don’t belong to their husbands, was how critics castigated the article. One woman wrote a Blog saying, “Breastfeeding does not hurt marriages. Selfish fathers hurt marriages." Less charitably, one blogger claimed that I had equated breastfeeding with adultery, which is one of the stupidest things I have ever read.
My article, of course, said none of these things. So here is my real position.
So why did I write my article? Because when we make breastfeeding an outright obsession, we cause harm to those families for whom the practice is a hardship. For instance, many families are absolutely dependent on a wife’s income for their basic sustenance. So a few weeks after having a baby, a mom will often be forced to return to work. She will feel extremely guilty at not being able to breastfeed during the day. Should we dig in the knife by telling her that she is harming her children? Since formula, albeit as a lesser alternative, exists, should we make her feel that quitting a necessary job must be prioritized over her rent and food money for her children? To be sure, it would be much better, of course, if she were to stay home with her baby. But for many women, that is simply not an option. And yes, I realize that she can express milk. But for many women, who are already overrun with too many job and household responsibilities, the added chore of having to express milk prior to rushing to work, after getting their other kids ready for school and making lunch, becomes the straw that breaks the camel’s back.
Then there are all the women who simply cannot breastfeed do to medical considerations. Many moms simply don’t have enough milk. And every time they read one of these article about how cruel it is not to breastfeed, they feel like inadequate mothers.
Furthermore, however much people will disagree with and condemn me, I have counseled many marriageswhere breastfeeding became an impediment to romance. We can criticize those husbands all we want for not being understanding about their children’s need to be suckled. And in those counseling sessions, I did. I made it clear to the men that love and romance is holistic, encompassing a spouse as woman, wife, and mother. But in the final analysis if a husband and wife both agree that the little time they have together is being compromised by the constantly demands of breastfeeding, then it is for them to make the choice of an alternative, without those wives being made to feel like they are horrendous moms.
In my article, I gave the example of a couple who appeared on Shalom in the Home, even though the breastfeeding aspect was not included in their on-air story. Their marriage was passionate and their attraction strong until the birth of their baby boy. This should not surprise us since a Harvard study indicates that sexual activity between a husband and wife decreases by about 74 percent in the first year after the birth of a child. What increased the loss of eroticism for this particular couple was that the mother nursed her baby constantly, so much so that the husband no longer felt he even had a place in their marital bed and moved into a spare bedroom.
In this couple’s case, the wife would nurse the baby in bed and both would fall asleep. I am, in general, a great opponent of children sleeping in the matrimonial bed because, first, it is inappropriate, and second, it prevents parents from being lovers, and a bad and loveless marriage is ultimately detrimental to the children who are a product of that marriage. Giving up breastfeeding was the right choice for this couple because the wife herself complained that she was too tired for sex since she was up most of the night feeding. She also said that she and her husband had stopped going out together on dates because she had to be back to feed the baby. In the first year after the baby’s birth, they did not go out alone together even once. When she put the baby on the bottle, her love life was restored and she and her husband were happier.
Who has the right to judge this couple, and condemn the parents for being selfish, when their only desire was to recapture the affection that had produced the baby in the first place?
While I am a staunch advocate of breastfeeding, and would not recommend the above advice for most couples, including myself, if forced to choose between a couple’s romantic life and supplementing breastfeeding with the bottle, I would advocate the bottle. Period. And I will endure the withering criticism that I have of late to stand by this advice. I am in the business of saving families and reversing the out of control American divorce rate. The best thing for children is to see their parents in love rather than the children becoming yo-yos of a divorced household, pulled between Mom and Dad every other weekend.
Even so, breastfeeding remains the correct decision for the vast majority of couples and husbands should go out of their way to support and encourage their wives in making that choice. However in a case where both spouses agree that breastfeeding has come between them, then the baby will survive perfectly well on a bottle.
Simple Wishes Hands Free Pumping Bustier Review & Giveaway!
Sunday, June 6, 2010
Did You Know Breastfeeding Ruins Marriages?
Tuesday, June 1, 2010
For The Preggos: Things No One Tells You About Breastfeeding
Monday, May 24, 2010
The Nursing In Public War





Friday, May 21, 2010
The Wonderful Things About Boobies


Tuesday, May 18, 2010
Baby Bond Review and Giveaway!

Tuesday, February 9, 2010
The Power Of Twitter
Tuesday, January 5, 2010
The Kind Of Mommy I Am
I love holding Austin. I tried a year and a half to get pregnant with him, lost 2 babies, feared my entire pregnancy that I would lose him, had to leave him in the Level 2 NICU for 2 weeks... Why in the WORLD would I ever put him down? You can't spoil a newborn right?!
Consider Austin the most spoiled rotten little cutie you have ever seen in your life... But I don't care. I spoiled him and I will continue to. He's going to be 40 weeks this week, he's allowed to be born now, so may be I'll stop carrying him since my uterus isn't supposed to be anymore! Or may be I'll just keep waiting for Christopher to get home to shower and brush my teeth ;)
I love cloth diapers. They are cheap. They are super duper cute. I don't know why everyone doesn't use them... Throw them in the washing machine at dinner, hang them up to dry over night... Done... So easy. It's not like I'm doing anything but holding Austin all day anyways! I have time for one extra load of laundry every 1-2 days!
I love slings. I hate those stupid bulky heavy infant carriers. I love holding my baby (as discussed above...) so my Baby K'Tan sling is perfect. It keeps my little man snuggled up to me and keeps us both pretty warm! It's so easy in the store and I can cover his face so that he doesn't get germs. People don't ask to hold him when he's in it, and if they were to and I didn't want them to, I could say "sorry it's really hard to get him in and out" (which it is kinda) (BTW this is for back when he was really early and I was more afraid of germies than I am now!). There are a few other baby carriers out there that I long for, but for now my Baby K'Tan is perfect!
Here I go, I will admit it... I did NOT want to breastfeed. I thought it was weird. I thought something sucking on my breasts was going to be odd and strange. I decided halfway through my pregnancy that I would give it a try. Why in the world would I turn something down without trying, especially since it is FREE?! I went to a breastfeeding class and BAM I was sold. Watching those little babies nurse was so heart warming and gave me fuzzy wuzzys! When I had Austin and he was in the NICU pumping was all I could do for him. That was the only thing that I had that I could give him that no one else in that place could and it made me feel so incredibly special and like FINALLY I was helping him. When I look down and he's all droopy eyed, falling asleep, so content... My heart melts. I don't know what it is about it, but I really love it. Plus it's cheap, and I now weigh 10 pounds less than my prepregnancy weight, and I chalk it all up to breastfeeding!
So far everything I had hoped and wished for has worked out for us really well! There are labels I could use (attachment parenting, crunchy, etc) but instead I'd like to just be Katie, Austin's mommy!
In Bumble B news,
Austin is getting so big. He smiles and he squeals when he's excited. He squeals at me and Christopher when we're playing with him and tickling him and being silly, and he squeals at his seahorse. It's so so funny! He's a pretty happy baby. I wish more of his awake time was during the day and less the middle of the night. I feel bad for making him go to sleep or leaving him awake and going to sleep when he's wide awake, but what can ya do?
His eyes are getting bluer (I hope they stay!), he's smiling with gorgeous dimples, he has the most beautiful skin, he's picking his head up and turning it, he's grasping things, and his fingernails grow faster than anything I've ever seen!
Here is Austin talking to Mr. Fussels :)
Friday, January 1, 2010
Happy New Year!
Last Monday the doctor told us we could start breastfeeding and only do a couple fortified bottles a day. Last Wednesday (the day before Christmas Eve) we went to see the lactation consultant at the hospital and she got us on track. I eventually got on a schedule where Austin was getting a fortified bottle in the morning and in the evening. I was really scared that he would lose weight and I was very very anxious for this past Wednesday. I took him to the Best Fed Baby support group at the hospital to have him weighed. On December 22nd he was 5 pounds 11 ounces. The pediatrician said she would like to see him gain an ounce a day. So at the Best Fed Baby I was looking for 6 pounds 2 ounces. I really didn't think he would have done it. I saw a change in him overnight during his last growth spurt. I didn't see much change this week. Once we got little man on the scale, he proved to me to never underestimate him! He weighed in at a whopping 6 pounds 3 ounces! I am so proud of him! He is obviously getting enough to eat and not burning too many calories doing so! So now we are down to a bottle at night that his daddy gets to feed him and I pump. I'll go again next week to make sure he's gaining what he still needs to be!
I'm also looking to make my first big cloth diaper purchase. Cottonbabies has Bumgenious buy 5 get 1 free. Hopefully I can scoop some up before the offer is up! I really want to try Flips as well.The initial purchase is so much but I can't wait to start. I hate disposables. And half the time I change Austin and 2 minutes later I have to again! The Flips with just the changable inserts would be so awesome for times like those! Austin's butt is getting a lot bigger so it's almost time for him to start! I have some birthday and Christmas money that I hope to use on them very soon!
Austin wakes up ever 2-3 hours to eat. I am so so tired. We nap until 10ish usually in the morning. Yesterday we went to Target to get some wipes and things. I was exhausted! Getting him ready, everything ready, me ready, shopping with him, it's all very tiring. My sister in law could never stay home. She was always on the go. I have no clue how she did this. Going to Target has made me miserable for 2 days! Thinking about it- I haven't slept for more than 3 hours at a time in a month. That is so crazy to think about. I'm surprised I am functioning at all! But I suppose you get used to it!
I love being Austin's mommy. He is so amazing. He is so funny. He's starting to talk and smile. When he's on his belly he is lifting his head and turning it the other way. He LOVES his little seahorse friend my mom gave him for Christmas. We named him Mr. Fussels because that is what I call Austin when he fusses.
